Editorial
19.11.2015
By Aivars Jurcans

It is not that often when news from the Riga stock exchange trigger a public discussion. The public announcement in September when 43.25% of the shares outstanding (or, 45,187,392 shares to be precise) in Ventspils Nafta AS had been sold by Latvijas Naftas Tranzits AS to Euromin Holdings (Cyprus) Limited was an exception that caused a very heated debate. Just to remind, the total reported transaction value was EUR 79.98 million, while the price per single share was EUR 1.77. This price implied the enteprise value of EUR 304.20 million and valued the VN business at 5.1x its year 2014 earnings before interest, tax, depreciation and amortisation (EBITDA).

Is this an adequate price, or, as some claim, have we just witnessed a steal of the century?

Before trying to answer that, here are some hard facts and figures about Ventspils Nafta:

  • On a consolidated basis the Group has reported negative after-tax earnings of EUR (13.98) million on revenues of EUR 161.87 million in 2014 and EUR (66.24) million on revenues of EUR 166.73 million in 2013.
  • Only in 2015 the Group’s performance trend has reversed itself as it reported EUR 21.22 million in net profit on revenues of EUR 95.66 million in the first half of the year.
  • From the published financial statements it is not entirely clear how the Group calculates its EBITDA, but in their own estimate it has amounted to EUR 59.41 million and EUR 51.89 million in 2014 and 2013 respectively.
  • The Group has 104,479,519 shares outstanding, with a nominal value of EUR 1.40 each; its share capital is EUR 146.27 million, while the book equity amounted to EUR 476.37 million as at the end of 2014.
  • Over the first 6 months of 2015 the share price on the stock exchange has been fluctuating between EUR 1.01 and EUR 1.25, with the average being EUR 1.11.

A few weeks later Financial and Capital Market Commission ruled that the mandatory offer by Euromin to minority shareholders should be made at a price of EUR 4.56 per share. Simply put, the law requires that the price applied in such offers must be the highest of the following - the top price that Euromin had paid for the shares over the last 12 months, the weighted average price for the shares traded on the stock exchange over the last 12 months, or the value of the company’s net assets per share. The FCMC-approved price of EUR 4.56 per share reflects the net asset value as per the last audited financial statements of VN as at the end of 2014.

Thus we are having at least three different price points to consider – the average trading price of EUR 1.11, the transaction price of EUR 1.77 and the mandatory offer price of EUR 4.56. Which one, if any, would approximate the fair value?

According to corporate finance theory the market price of a publicly traded share is forward-looking, i.e., it reflects the market’s view on the ability of the company to generate positive returns to its shareholders. In other words, the value of any security reflects the present value of future cash flows that are discounted back by using a discount rate that reflects the riskiness of those cash flows. Of course, this comes with some caveats, one of them being that the market where said securities are traded is a transparent and a liquid one.

The average share price of EUR 1.11 has been calculated from 336 transactions with 86,370 shares changing hands, or from the turnover of mere EUR 94,648. Using this price level as a reference the transaction price would represent a 61% premium. But it is very hard indeed to argue that any price derived at this low a turnover would be the fair market value.

The net asset value, in comparison, is more backward-looking and reflects what the company has achieved and accumulated so far. And corporate finance teaches us that past results are no guarantee for future performance. The share price of EUR 4.56 implies a market capitalisation of EUR 476.73 million, or an enterprise value of the company of EUR 596.00 million. This would translate into an EV/ EBITDA ratio of 10.0x.

To assess whether this is high or low one needs to find a point of reference. Admittedly, there are not that many publicly quoted companies of a similar profile to compare with. One of the precious few, Royal Vopak, is among the biggest tank storage providers for oil and gas products globally, with 73 terminals in 26 countries and total assets of EUR 5.4 billion. In 2014 Vopak reported consolidated revenues of EUR 1.3 billion, EBITDA of EUR 707.7 million and earnings per diluted share of EUR 1.94. With its shares recently trading on the Euronext Amsterdam stock exchange at c. EUR 37.00, the company is valued at an EV/EBITDA multiple of 8.74x and a Price-to-Earnings (trailing twelve months) ratio of 17.94x, according to Bloomberg.

Premia and discounts are factors that make valuation less of a science and more of an art. Given the huge differences in size, diversification and profitability between Royal Vopak and VN it would hardly be appropriate to apply the Royal Vopak multiples without calibration. To make them more comparable it could probably make sense to adjust the multiple by, say, 20%. Such adjustment would produce an EBITDA multiple of 7.0x and would result in an EV of EUR 415.39 million and the price per share of EUR 2.83. This would represent a neat 60% premium over the Euromin transaction price.

Of course, the buyer with this transaction crosses the important thresholds of 50% and 75% of shareholding and acquires full control over the Group. Normally such transactions would call for a premium, ingeniously being named the “control premium”. Depending on the source, this premium is suggested as being in the range of 20-30%. But, again, what would be that benchmark share price to apply the premium to in this case? As already argued above, the market price level is not very representative. Also, in the case of VN any such premium might be offset partially or in full by a discount applied to compensate for the lack of liquidity.

A holder of 43.25% of shares has a strong minority position but not enough for exercising or acquiring control. When there is only one party familiar with the company, with an incentive to buy and the resources to afford it, the seller’s alternatives become somewhat limited. Selling the shares in smaller lots on the exchange is likely to depress the price even more and take too long a time to be feasible. Given the shareholder structure, seeking another buyer for the block of shares does not appear as too realistic an option either. None of the above supports the bargaining position of the seller, of course.

Any transaction has a rationale both for the buyer and for the seller, and both parties are guided by the considerations that we as general public are not privy to. It is conceivable that, because of the assymetry of information, the sellers know something that the buyer and the rest of us do not. And this “something” leads them to believe that EUR 1.77 is a good price to accept.

To conclude, for an outsider without a deeper knowledge and understanding of VN’s business prospects it is hard to peg with any degree of precision what the fair value of shares should be. The very back-of-envelope analysis might suggest a value corridor of up to 7.0x EBITDA which would place the actual transaction price at the lower end of the range. And the assymetric information combined with the differences in bargaining power for sure have had an impact on that as well!

Sincerely,
Aivars Jurcans
editor@mergers.lv

< Newer
Season's Greetings!
Older >
My Board, My Family
61 Comments
To comment please Log in or Register at Mergers.lv
Or Log In with:
We welcome thoughtful comments from readers. Please comply with our guidelines.
01-09-2022, 00:48
jassica
wrote: valuable data on points that bounty are intrigued on for this magnificent post.Admiring the time and exertion you put into your b!.. aka ms
15-08-2022, 17:30
robinjack
wrote: I was suggested this website by my cousin. I am not sure whether this post is written by him as nobody else know such detailed about my trouble. You are incredible! Thanks! money transmitter license bitcoin
06-08-2022, 15:43
Seo Expert
wrote: Our Partner provides the best free quotation at your doorstep. We are the best in Logistics service & Packers and Movers, Office and Home Shifting, Packers and Movers, Household Shifting, Movers and Packers, Transportation Service . Packers and Movers Noida to Pune
06-08-2022, 15:25
Seo Expert
wrote: Are you searching for the best Packers and Movers? Yes! Listcry provides the most reputed packers and movers from that know how to moving and packing valuable in the most professional way possible. Packers and Movers Noida to Pune
06-08-2022, 14:08
Seo Expert
wrote: Allianz Packers and Movers Pvt. Ltd. is a leading Packing and Moving Company offers varied packing and moving services such as loading unloading service, door to door packing and moving service, home moving service, office relocation service, house shifting, car & bike transport, cargo, insurance service and packers and movers in India at reasonable prices Packers and Movers Noida to Bangalore
11-07-2022, 23:11
jassica
wrote: howdy, your sites are better than average. I value your work. Lloyds bank mortgages for over 65s
11-07-2022, 13:12
jassica
wrote: This is truly a decent and educational, containing all data furthermore greatly affects the new innovation. A debt of gratitude is in order for sharing it https //aka.ms/remoteconnect iniciar sesion
05-07-2022, 20:05
jassica
wrote: i read a ton of stuff and i found that the method for composing to clearifing that precisely need to say was great so i am inspired and ilike to come back again in future.. restaurant menu prices
04-07-2022, 18:09
jassica
wrote: extremely intriguing continue posting. company reviews
15-06-2022, 15:22
robinjack
wrote: I would like to thank you for the efforts youve got produced in writing this post. I am hoping the exact same most effective function from you within the long term too. In fact your creative writing abilities has inspired me to start my very own BlogEngine blog now. Lacey Pest Control
12-06-2022, 13:23
ALIXXXXXX
wrote: Wonderful article. The actual publish impacts lots of immediate problems in our culture. All of us cannot be uninvolved in order to these types of problems. This particular publish provides plans as well as ideas. Really educational as well as useful. Sunset cruise mumbai
12-06-2022, 13:21
ALIXXXXXX
wrote: Wonderful article. The actual publish impacts lots of immediate problems in our culture. All of us cannot be uninvolved in order to these types of problems. This particular publish provides plans as well as ideas. Really educational as well as useful. Sunset cruise mumbai
12-06-2022, 13:20
ALIXXXXXX
wrote: Wonderful article. The actual publish impacts lots of immediate problems in our culture. All of us cannot be uninvolved in order to these types of problems. This particular publish provides plans as well as ideas. Really educational as well as useful. Sunset cruise mumbai
12-06-2022, 13:20
ALIXXXXXX
wrote: Wonderful article. The actual publish impacts lots of immediate problems in our culture. All of us cannot be uninvolved in order to these types of problems. This particular publish provides plans as well as ideas. Really educational as well as useful. Sunset cruise mumbai
12-06-2022, 13:20
ALIXXXXXX
wrote: Wonderful article. The actual publish impacts lots of immediate problems in our culture. All of us cannot be uninvolved in order to these types of problems. This particular publish provides plans as well as ideas. Really educational as well as useful. Sunset cruise mumbai
01-06-2022, 12:53
robinjack
wrote: Oh my goodness! an incredible write-up dude. Many thanks Nevertheless My business is experiencing trouble with ur rss . Do not know why Cannot enroll in it. Perhaps there is anyone obtaining identical rss problem? Anyone who knows kindly respond. Thnkx reservation system
19-05-2022, 07:51
wat123
wrote:
เกมออนไลน์ที่ได้รับความนิยมมากที่สุดในตอนนี้ปี 2022
slot joker
JOKER GAME
19-05-2022, 07:51
wat123
wrote:
เกมออนไลน์ที่ได้รับความนิยมมากที่สุดในตอนนี้ปี 2022
slot joker
JOKER GAME
19-05-2022, 07:51
wat123
wrote:
เกมออนไลน์ที่ได้รับความนิยมมากที่สุดในตอนนี้ปี 2022
slot joker
JOKER GAME
19-05-2022, 07:50
wat123
wrote: เกมออนไลน์ที่ได้รับความนิยมมากที่สุดในตอนนี้ปี 2022
https://jokerslot191.com/
https://jokergame191.net/
19-05-2022, 07:50
wat123
wrote: เกมออนไลน์ที่ได้รับความนิยมมากที่สุดในตอนนี้ปี 2022
https://jokerslot191.com/
https://jokergame191.net/
08-05-2022, 11:11
Ghazanfar Ali Khatri
wrote: Mmm.. estimable to be here in your report or notify, whatever, I repute I should moreover process strong for my have website want I play some salubrious further updated busy in your location. abbotsford landscaping companies
01-05-2022, 15:06
Ghazanfar Ali Khatri
wrote: Wow, cool post. I'd like to write like this too - taking time and real hard work to make a great article... but I put things off too much and never seem to get started. Thanks though. Packers and Movers Chennai to Bangalore
01-05-2022, 15:06
Ghazanfar Ali Khatri
wrote: Wow, cool post. I'd like to write like this too - taking time and real hard work to make a great article... but I put things off too much and never seem to get started. Thanks though. Packers and Movers Chennai to Bangalore
16-04-2022, 21:21
BPSLOT
wrote: Agen Bpslot merupakan situs judi slot online Diindonesia Yang terpercaya dengan tingkat kemenangan tertinggi.
Ditambah dengan pelayanan dan keamanan yang terpercaya bagi para petaruh di Indonesia.
Dengan menerapkan teknologi terbaru serta proses Slot Deposit Pulsa Tanpa Potongan sudah bisa dilakukan
Cukup dengan menggunakan 1 ID saja, anda sudah bisa memainkan berbagai permainan langsung
seperti judi bola online, live casino, slot game, dan jenis game lainnya dapat dimainkan dengan aman dan nyaman di Bpslot
16-04-2022, 21:21
BPSLOT
wrote: Agen Bpslot merupakan situs judi slot online Diindonesia Yang terpercaya dengan tingkat kemenangan tertinggi.
Ditambah dengan pelayanan dan keamanan yang terpercaya bagi para petaruh di Indonesia.
Dengan menerapkan teknologi terbaru serta proses Slot Deposit Pulsa Tanpa Potongan sudah bisa dilakukan
Cukup dengan menggunakan 1 ID saja, anda sudah bisa memainkan berbagai permainan langsung
seperti judi bola online, live casino, slot game, dan jenis game lainnya dapat dimainkan dengan aman dan nyaman di Bpslot
16-04-2022, 21:21
BPSLOT
wrote: Agen Bpslot merupakan situs judi slot online Diindonesia Yang terpercaya dengan tingkat kemenangan tertinggi.
Ditambah dengan pelayanan dan keamanan yang terpercaya bagi para petaruh di Indonesia.
Dengan menerapkan teknologi terbaru serta proses Slot Deposit Pulsa Tanpa Potongan sudah bisa dilakukan
Cukup dengan menggunakan 1 ID saja, anda sudah bisa memainkan berbagai permainan langsung
seperti judi bola online, live casino, slot game, dan jenis game lainnya dapat dimainkan dengan aman dan nyaman di Bpslot
02-04-2022, 14:39
Ghazanfar Ali Khatri
wrote: Pod system พอตไฟฟ้า smok ร้าน ขาย บุหรี่ไฟฟ้า ราคาถูกฟรี ครบวงจร ของแท้ 100% เพจจำหน่ายอุปกรณ์สำหรับ mod pod คือ pod1688 ส่งด่วน กทม 24 ชม. กลุ่มบุหรี่ไฟฟ้า
02-04-2022, 14:31
Ghazanfar Ali Khatri
wrote: Increase your exposure on social media! Check out our deals and buy Instagram Followers, Buy Youtube Subscribers, and more! Fast, cheap, and 24/7 Support buy 4000 watch hours on youtube
02-04-2022, 14:31
Ghazanfar Ali Khatri
wrote: Increase your exposure on social media! Check out our deals and buy Instagram Followers, Buy Youtube Subscribers, and more! Fast, cheap, and 24/7 Support buy 4000 watch hours on youtube
30-11-2021, 23:46
thomas jack
wrote: It is very informative post thanks for sharing the information. candle boxes wholesale, wholesale corrugated box
30-11-2021, 23:45
thomas jack
wrote: It is very informative post thanks for sharing the information. candle boxes wholesale, wholesale corrugated box
30-11-2021, 23:45
thomas jack
wrote: It is very informative post thanks for sharing the information. candle boxes wholesale, wholesale corrugated box
30-11-2021, 23:45
thomas jack
wrote: It is very informative post thanks for sharing the information. candle boxes wholesale, wholesale corrugated box
30-11-2021, 23:45
thomas jack
wrote: It is very informative post thanks for sharing the information. candle boxes wholesale, wholesale corrugated box
02-11-2021, 14:31
Karter221
wrote: I found so many interesting stuff in your blog especially its discussion. Really its great article. Keep it up. https://altex-spb.ru/
01-11-2021, 18:09
Karter221
wrote: Your article is extremely helpful exceptionally fascinating subject i am looking that sort of post thank for imparting to us keep it up. Custom packaging Boxes
01-11-2021, 13:12
Karter221
wrote: I definitely enjoying every little bit of it. It is a great website and nice share. I want to thank you. Good job! You guys do a great blog, and have some great contents. Keep up the good work. joker888
28-10-2021, 21:36
hawkemikyle
wrote: I love significantly your own post! I look at all post is great. I discovered your personal content using bing search. Discover my webpage is a great one as you.I work to create several content this post. Once more you can thank you and keep it create! Enjoy! instagram reseller panel
28-10-2021, 14:40
hawkemikyle
wrote: Such a very useful article. Very interesting to read this article.I would like to thank you for the efforts you had made for writing this awesome article. جزيرة فرسان
27-10-2021, 21:24
hawkemikyle
wrote: I needed to thank you for this phenomenal read!! I unquestionably adored each and every piece of it. I have you bookmarked your site to look at the new stuff you post. instagram followers
26-10-2021, 14:12
hawkemikyle
wrote: I love significantly your own post! I look at all post is great. I discovered your personal content using bing search. Discover my webpage is a great one as you.I work to create several content this post. Once more you can thank you and keep it create! Enjoy! immobilien papenburg
25-10-2021, 16:45
hawkemikyle
wrote: You have made some decent points there. I looked on the internet for more information about the issue and found most people will go along with your views on this web site. doonungth.com
25-10-2021, 16:45
hawkemikyle
wrote: You have made some decent points there. I looked on the internet for more information about the issue and found most people will go along with your views on this web site. doonungth.com
24-10-2021, 14:35
hawkemikyle
wrote: I truly welcome this superb post that you have accommodated us. I guarantee this would be valuable for the vast majority of the general population. More Help
24-10-2021, 14:35
hawkemikyle
wrote: I truly welcome this superb post that you have accommodated us. I guarantee this would be valuable for the vast majority of the general population. More Help
24-10-2021, 14:34
hawkemikyle
wrote: I truly welcome this superb post that you have accommodated us. I guarantee this would be valuable for the vast majority of the general population. More Help
13-10-2021, 09:52
Muhammad Ali
wrote: Nice post. I was checking constantly this blog and I’m impressed! Extremely useful info specially the last part I care for such information a lot. I was seeking this certain info for a long time. Thank you and good luck. asda walmartone
12-10-2021, 16:07
Muhammad Ali
wrote: I got too much interesting stuff on your blog. I guess I am not the only one having all the enjoyment here! Keep up the good work. Ottawa Rims
09-10-2021, 10:00
Muhammad Ali
wrote: Excellent to be visiting your blog again, it has been months for me. Rightly, this article that I've been served for therefore long. I want this article to finish my assignment within the faculty, and it has the same topic together with your article. Thanks for the ton of valuable help, nice share. 화이트먹튀
05-10-2021, 19:32
Muhammad Ali
wrote: The mattress is a great place to shop for a good deal of information. A great way to get a good idea is to buy a foam latex mattress. Also, a great way to get a memory foam topper is to purchase a mattress that is hypoallergenic. truck mattress
05-10-2021, 13:28
hasnain khatri
wrote: Impressive web site, Distinguished feedback that I can tackle. Im moving forward and may apply to my current job as a pet sitter, which is very enjoyable, but I need to additional expand. Regards. 먹튀
04-10-2021, 19:26
Muhammad Ali
wrote: I think this is an informative post and it is very useful and knowledgeable. therefore, I would like to thank you for the efforts you have made in writing this article. visit site
04-10-2021, 19:25
Muhammad Ali
wrote: I think this is an informative post and it is very useful and knowledgeable. therefore, I would like to thank you for the efforts you have made in writing this article. visit site
03-10-2021, 13:19
hasnain khatri
wrote: Please let me know if you’re looking for a article writer for your site. You have some really great posts and I feel I would be a good asset. If you ever want to take some of the load off, I’d absolutely love to write some material for your blog in exchange for a link back to mine. Please send me an email if interested. Thank you! nearest restaurants
02-10-2021, 16:05
kuzey
wrote: Excellent blog! I found it while surfing around on Google. Content of this page is unique as well as well researched. Appreciate it. places to eat near me
30-09-2021, 13:42
kuzey
wrote: Its a great pleasure reading your post.Its full of information I am looking for and I love to post a comment that "The content of your post is awesome" Great work. 먹튀검증사이트
30-09-2021, 13:42
kuzey
wrote: Its a great pleasure reading your post.Its full of information I am looking for and I love to post a comment that "The content of your post is awesome" Great work. 먹튀검증사이트
27-09-2021, 11:35
hasnain khatri
wrote: Thanks for sharing the post.. parents are worlds best person in each lives of individual..they need or must succeed to sustain needs of the family. disposable face mask
10-01-2018, 16:42
Edgars Skrinda
wrote: Apgrozāmie līdzekļi no Cityfinances https://www.cityfinances.lv/apgrozamie-lidzekli/
07-01-2018, 09:52
Edgars Skrinda
wrote: Finansējums uzņēmumiem viens no aizdevums biznesam veidiem https://www.cityfinances.lv/finansejums-uznemumiem/

Subscribe
Sign up to receive an extract from
our latest M&A Intelligence Report
Sign up
more updates...